Smithville High School
| Female | Male | |
| 1986 | — | Hud Bauman |
| 1987 | Kathy Mast | Terry Shane |
| 1988 | Trish Huffman | Lee King |
| 1989 | Kelly Cottle | Greg First |
| 1990 | Wendi Schrock | Tom Ballinger |
| 1991 | Sharon Hartzler | Matt Allen |
| 1992 | Heide Karley | Eric Smith |
| 1993 | Heidi Schrock | Chad Marthey |
| 1994 | Mary Beth Thompson | Ryan Nissley |
| 1995 | Steph Moss & Jodi Schrock | Ben Olsen |
| 1996 | Hannah Naumoff | Brad Horst |
| 1997 | Laura Ziegler | — |
| 1998 | Chrissy Craemer, Tiffanie Tate | Matt Saris |
| 1999 | Hanna Rufener | Andrew Saurer |
| 2000 | Tisha Horst | Ryan Imhoff |
| 2001 | Brook Hollenbaugh | Gabe Middleton |
| 2002 | Haley Workman | Kyle Indermuhle |
| 2003 | Kate Ickes | Kyle Kauffman |
| 2004 | Alicia Hoff | Jon Gale |
| 2005 | Lindsey Beichler | Aaron Long, Andrew Salis |
| 2006 | Heather Steiner | Bobby Denning |
| 2007 | Lori Ickes | Kevin Beichler |
| 2008 | Beth Yoder | Calvin Baird |
| 2009 | Bethany Indermuhle | Tyler Bates |
| 2010 | Jenna Pew | Corey Caldwell |
| 2011 | Jessi Hartzler | Jonathan Roseler |
| 2012 | Tara Schaffter | Paul Kelby |
| 2013 | Kylie Frizell | Alec Bates |
| 2014 | Adriana Fike | Thomas Weiner |
| 2015 | Maggie Poorman | Wyatt Baer |
| 2016 | Emily Horst | Isaiah Viator |
| 2017 | Jordan McConnell | Jacob McConnell |
| 2018 | Emma Leway | Cole Smith |
| 2019 | Kenzie Brookover | Braden Smith |
| 2020 | Sarah Meech | Andrew Beery |
| 2021 | Kiley Kalina | Caleb Keib |
| 2022 | Brooke Fatzinger | Carter Fath |
| 2023 | Maddilyn Brillhart | Carter Piatt |
| 2024 | Naomi Keib | Colt Zollinger |