Rittman High School
| Female | Male | |
| 1986 | Sharon Tyler | Todd Piatt |
| 1987 | Debbie Chipps, Cynthia Atkinson | Tom Lycans, Mike Knapic |
| 1988 | Peggy Webb | Jeff Craddock |
| 1989 | Wendy Wilkinson | John Ramsier |
| 1990 | Paula Webb | John Tomlinson |
| 1991 | Shelly Steiner | Matt Beaumont |
| 1992 | Carla Ramsier | Joe Copenhaver |
| 1993 | Sheri Lindenmuth | Joe Tomlinson |
| 1994 | Amanda Leatherman | Tim Thompson |
| 1995 | Kitsie Steiner | Greg Packard |
| 1996 | Amy Stamper | Ryan Rastorfer |
| 1997 | Jessica Morris | Steve Thompson |
| 1998 | Rebecca Berry | Josh Carey |
| 1999 | Leah Dheel | Jude LaChance |
| 2000 | April Dotterer | Matt Carpenter |
| 2001 | Courtney Tisher | Bubba Porter |
| 2002 | Jamie Adams | Nick Carpenter |
| 2003 | Kari Craddock | Scott Jones |
| 2004 | Rachel Lynn Tisher | Christopher A. Robertson |
| 2005 | Halee Adams | Tom Staley |
| 2006 | Rachel Powell | Adam Jones |
| 2007 | Shannon Whims | Drew Fetter |
| 2008 | Chelsea Raines | Kenny Pease |
| 2009 | Brooke Bauman | Nate Gilkerson |
| 2010 | Aimee Cline | Barrett Gasser |
| 2011 | Gretchen Baisden | Patrick Rufener |
| 2012 | Crystal Barber | Lance Horner |
| 2013 | Katie Emerson | Anthony Heater |
| 2014 | Emily Berger | Zach Vaughn |
| 2015 | Rebecca Gasser | Ty Ramsier |
| 2016 | Madelynn McDermott | Mathew McMillan |
| 2017 | Kendall Leatherman | Manny Garza |
| 2018 | Cora Wilson | Kaleb Bauman |
| 2019 | Erica Gasser | Connor Stuart |
| 2020 | Bri Busic | Kyle Scheibe |
| 2021 | Sara Erne | Sevi Garza |
| 2022 | Isabelle Shreve | Bryce Holmes |